To Bark or Not to Bark

[dnstehly]

I’ve extolled the virtues of using bark in carving designs in responses in several earlier threads. I just finished this piece which I believe really emphasizes what I mean. The design is a slick bird head, which I call simply Raptor. This one is a 40 in. cane done in black sugar maple. The natural finish is hand rubbed Formby’s tung oil. On the left side of the head I was able to retain a depressed area of bark that I think really gives some character. Contrast it to the bare right side of the head and tell me which side you think has more appeal.

[papasar]

Neat carving.
The side with bark looks like the raptor has a floppy ear. IMHO
Bill K.

[Alice in Wonderland]

The first picture has more character something not everybody can show.to me ,the wood is so individual that I always leave it if it shows imperfections,

[Lonewolfcarver]

Definitely the left. The bark adds character to the piece without taking away from the carving. Very nice work.

[Mottles]

Really nice, thank you for sharing. Geez I love bark...I think I'll change my sign-in name to Bark Lady...oh the left side for sure.
Kathy

[Ron T]

Hi David,

Another beautiful cane carving. There's no doubt the bark give contrast and character and lets our mind see more on the raptor's head.

[Iowa Carver]

Nice carving. I think the 2 sides work well together like that.

Corey

[Colin-Partridge]

Love it both ways I think how ever you percive that it should be is just great. I have done many of these sticks and I just let nature dictate to me what should happen. Natural is always beautiful there is no way you could duplicate that no matter how hard you tired.
Colin

[dnstehly]

Thanks to all. I'm pleased that you agree. I always profess the motto, "Let the wood be wood!" If there is an imperfection that does not make the piece unstable, I try to work it into the design.