[Paul_Guraedy]

Well done Susan!!! You have given me new perspective in the art vs. craft argument. Although, I still think that there is a definite "pecking order" among artists. But then, that is true for most human activities. Just listen to the comments of "I use oil paints only, My chain saw is a Husqvarna, I drive a Jaguar, etc." Like Colin, I see a lot of big chickens drawing a bead on woodcarvers. I believe that we are gaining ground and I am convinced that a lot of our slow rise in the art field is due to our own actions and inactions.

Uppermost being that a lot of carvings illustrating relatively poor technique, design and finishing are winning awards in shows. I believe the major culprit is the low number of juried shows and increasing number of events with limited competition combined with the "somebody has to win" situation.

But, you have given me points to ponder in this controversy that have never occurred to me before. One being limited production. Being a slow carver and turning out only a few pieces each year, I related to this immediately. I recently encountered the "size" issue; but, paid little attention. I am working on a barn owl (life size) and want to place it in a window made of old barn wood. Although the window will be somewhat less than "life size" it will still have to be large enough to look realistic. A good friend, upon hearing my description of what I am attempting commented, "I want one of your carvings; but, I don't have anywhere to display anything of that size. What are you going to do with it?" I have a place in mind in the new house we are building so paid little attention.

Now, you have me wondering where I am headed. My goal is to move into larger pieces with more "scene setting habitat". I agree with what I heard Keith Mueller say several years ago at a carving course, "Woodcarvers are too limited to carving monoliths." I sensed that he was right; but, am only now "listening" to him.

I will not change course, BUT, what will I do with these pieces?